What makes a couple photogenic? It's the ability to have fun and move naturally in front of the camera. That's. It. Just be comfortable and stop thinking about how you look. That's when you'll look your best, I promise.
For that reason, Page and Andrew were one of the most photogenic couples I've ever shot: they just loved each other and forgot the camera was there. They had fun. They *were* fun. Bloody hell, they even organised a firetruck to come to their wedding for photos. (Andrew is a fireman, and apparently that's a perk that accompanies the job.) The shadows of the stained glass in Immanuel Lutheran Church was just the icing on the cake.